Marketing Strategy and Delivery, Western Australia.

Marketing Strategy

Strategy before AI: why the thinking still comes first

AI makes good marketing faster. It makes unclear marketing faster too.

Few business conversations at the moment get far without someone mentioning AI. Leaders want to know whether their marketing team should be using it, which tools to choose, and whether they are already falling behind. 

Those are fair questions. AI is a genuinely useful set of tools, and businesses that learn to use it well will have an advantage. But in our experience, the most important question about AI and marketing is not which tool to use. It is whether the business is clear enough on its strategy to use any tool well. 

AI amplifies what is already there 

AI is very good at producing more, faster. It can draft content, summarise research, generate variations of an ad, analyse data and suggest ideas in seconds. That speed is valuable. It also means AI will amplify whatever direction it is given. 

If the business has a clear position, a defined audience and an agreed message, AI helps produce more of the right thing. If those foundations are missing, AI simply produces more of the wrong thing, more quickly. You end up with a higher volume of generic content that sounds like everyone else, aimed at nobody in particular. 

This is why we think about AI as a multiplier rather than a strategy. Multiplying a clear plan is powerful. Multiplying confusion is expensive. 

Picture two businesses using exactly the same AI tool to write their LinkedIn content. 

The first has agreed who it is trying to reach, what it wants to be known for and the three or four ideas it wants to own. Its team briefs the tool with that context, then edits each draft against a clear standard. Over time, its content builds a recognisable point of view, and its audience starts to associate the business with those ideas. 

The second has none of that. Each post is generated from a loose prompt about whatever seems topical that week. The writing is fluent and the volume is high, but the posts could have come from any business in its industry. Nothing accumulates. Six months later, it has published a great deal and is no clearer in the market than when it started. 

The tool was identical. The difference was the strategy behind it. 

What AI cannot decide for you 

There are parts of marketing that AI can support but cannot own. They are also the parts that matter most: 

  • Where the business is going. Which clients, services and markets to prioritise is a leadership decision, grounded in commercial judgement. 
  • What you want to be known for. Positioning involves choosing what to stand for and what to leave out. That takes an understanding of your clients, your competitors and your own strengths. 
  • What success looks like. The KPIs that leadership, sales and marketing agree on have to reflect the business, not the tool. 
  • Whether the work is right. AI can produce a draft. Someone who understands the business still has to judge whether it is accurate, on message and worth publishing. 

When these decisions are made well, AI becomes far more useful, because it has something clear to work towards. 

Where AI genuinely helps 

Once the strategy is in place, AI can add real value across a marketing programme. In our own work, the areas where it earns its place most consistently are: 

  1. Research and analysis. Summarising market information, reviewing competitor messaging and surfacing patterns in data more quickly. 
  1. Content development. Producing first drafts, outlines and variations that a senior person then shapes, checks and refines. 
  1. Testing ideas. Pressure testing a message, an argument or a campaign concept before it goes out. 
  1. Reporting and insight. Turning performance data into clearer summaries, so reviews spend less time on what happened and more on what to do next. 
  1. Operations. Automating repetitive tasks so that skilled people can spend their time on the work that needs judgement. 

In every case, AI sits behind the work rather than in front of it. The thinking, the judgement and the accountability remain with people. 

Using AI responsibly 

There is one more reason strategy has to come first. How a business uses AI says something about how it treats the information it holds. 

Clients, partners and staff trust a business with commercially sensitive material. Before AI becomes part of everyday marketing work, leaders should be clear on a few basics: which tools are approved, what information can and cannot be shared with them, and who reviews what AI produces before it is used. These are governance decisions, and they are much easier to make early than to unwind later. 

A short set of questions covers most of what a growth stage business needs to decide: 

  • Which AI tools are approved for work use, and under what type of account or licence? 
  • What information must never be entered into an AI tool, such as client data, financial detail or commercially sensitive plans? 
  • Who reviews AI-assisted work before it is published or sent, and what are they checking for? 
  • When should AI involvement be disclosed, to clients or in published content? 
  • Who owns the policy, and how often will it be reviewed as tools and risks change? 

Answering these does not require a long document. A page that everyone has read and agreed to is far more effective than a detailed policy nobody remembers. 

A sensible order of operations 

If you are considering how AI fits into your marketing, we would suggest this sequence: 

  1. Get clear on the business direction and the marketing strategy that supports it. 
  1. Settle your positioning, messaging and the audiences you most want to reach. 
  1. Agree how you will use AI, including the rules around information and review. 
  1. Introduce AI where it supports the plan, starting with the tasks where it saves the most time. 
  1. Measure whether it is improving outcomes, not just increasing output. 

The businesses that will benefit most from AI are not necessarily the ones that adopt it first. They are the ones that know exactly what they want it to help them achieve. 

How ready is your business to use AI well? Take our AI readiness check, or start a conversation with Russell about where AI fits in your marketing.

Author

  • Russell Smith - Founder, strategy and client leadership of Spark Growth Marketing

    Russell has a passion for global strategy, innovation, and ideas that move the world forward. He has spent his career working with businesses in more than 30 countries, building programs that focus on growth and value innovation. Russell focuses his time working with business leaders to understand, challenge, and unlock the value they have for the world, using marketing and insights to help them reach their vision.

Keep reading

More from the Spark team.