Your marketing probably grew the way your business did, one good decision at a time. The question is whether it still matches where the business is going.
Most growth stage businesses do not have bad marketing. They have marketing that was built for an earlier version of themselves. There is a website from when the company was smaller, and a brand that made sense three years ago. There are a few channels that clearly work, and a few that nobody is quite sure about.
None of that is unusual. It simply means there may be a gap between where the marketing is and where the business is headed. Marketing maturity is a way of seeing that gap clearly, so you can decide what to do about it.
What we mean by marketing maturity
Marketing maturity describes how well the parts of your marketing work together, and how closely they are tied to commercial results. It is not about how much activity you run or how much you spend. A business with a modest budget and a clear, coordinated programme is more mature than one running ten disconnected channels.
We describe maturity in four stages:
- Ad hoc. Marketing happens when there is time. Activity depends on one or two people, and results are hard to explain.
- Active. Plenty is being done and some of it works, but the pieces operate separately. The message changes depending on where you look.
- Structured. There is a clear position, a plan and a rhythm. Most channels support each other, and someone owns the outcome.
- Integrated. Strategy, brand, digital and campaigns run as one programme. Marketing is measured against commercial results and adjusted as the business moves.
Most businesses we meet sit at stage 2. They are busy, they have capable people, and they can point to things that have worked. What they lack is the connective tissue that turns individual efforts into a programme.
That connective tissue is less visible than a new website or a campaign, which is why it is so often missing. It includes an agreed position that everyone uses, a plan that sets priorities and sequence, a shared set of measures, and a regular review where the right people look at results together. None of these produce anything a customer sees directly. All of them determine whether the things a customer does see are working.
Stage 4 is not always the goal
It is tempting to read the stages as a ladder you should climb as fast as possible. That is not how we see it.
A business that is just starting out may sensibly sit at stage 2 while it finds its feet. A business about to enter a new market may need to rebuild parts of its foundation before it can scale. What matters is that where you sit is a decision, not an accident.
The six areas worth assessing
Different parts of the same business often sit at different stages. A company might have a strong brand and a well built website, but no reliable way of generating enquiries and no clear owner for the result. So it helps to look at marketing area by area. We use six:
- Positioning and messaging. How clearly does the business explain what it does, and does everyone explain it the same way?
- Brand. Does the brand reflect the business you are becoming, or the one you used to be?
- Website and digital platform. Is the website built for the audience you most want, and do you know what it contributes to revenue?
- Demand generation. Does new business come mainly from referral and reputation, or from a planned set of channels with clear targets?
- Measurement and reporting. Do you report on activity, such as clicks and posts, or on enquiries, pipeline and conversion?
- Ownership and team. Is one person or partner accountable for the result, or is marketing spread across suppliers who rarely speak to each other?
The lowest scoring area is usually the one holding the others back. A sharp campaign cannot fix an unclear message, and a new website cannot fix the lack of an owner.
Consider a business that scores well on brand and website, perhaps a 3 in each, but scores 1 on demand generation and 1 on ownership. Its instinct might be to refresh the website again, because that is the most visible part of its marketing. But the website is not what is holding it back. New business still depends on referral, and nobody is accountable for changing that. Until those two areas improve, a better website will simply be a better looking brochure that few people see.
This is why a maturity assessment is most useful as a way of deciding where to invest next, rather than as a score to improve for its own sake.
How to get an honest read
A maturity assessment is only useful if it is honest. A few habits make a real difference.
- Score where you are today, not where you plan to be. It is natural to give credit for work that is underway. The value comes from seeing the current position clearly.
- When two descriptions seem to fit, choose the lower one. It is a more reliable guide to where effort is needed.
- Involve more than one person. Leadership, sales and whoever manages marketing day to day will often score the same area differently. Those differences are useful in themselves, because they show where the picture is not shared.
- Write down the reason for each score. A single sentence explaining why you chose a stage makes the conversation that follows far more productive.
The aim is not a high score. It is a clear, shared view of where the business stands.
Why the order matters
Once a business sees its gaps, the natural instinct is to fix everything at once. We would encourage you to resist it.
Most marketing that disappoints was not badly done. It was done out of sequence, with a website built before the message was settled, or campaigns running before anyone agreed who they were for. The work itself was fine. The order was wrong.
The sequence we follow is simple. Understand where the business is headed. Decide what you want to be known for and say it consistently. Make sure the brand and platform reflect that position. Agree a plan and budget. Then run it, measure it and adjust it. Each step makes the next one cheaper and more effective.
What your stage suggests
If several areas sit at stage 1 or 2, the most valuable work is usually foundational: a clear position, a brand that reflects where you are going, a website built for the right audience, and a 12 month plan. We call this a Marketing Foundation.
If most areas sit at stage 2 or 3, you have real assets. The priority is joining them up, strengthening the weakest one or two areas, and putting a rhythm of measurement and review around the whole programme.
If you are mostly at stage 3 or 4, your marketing is working as a system. The value now comes from staying close to the business as it changes and keeping accountability high.
Whatever the overall picture, any area at stage 1 is worth fixing first.
See where your marketing stands. Our free Marketing Maturity Guide lets you score all six areas in about 15 minutes. It works best completed with one or two colleagues, because different people see different parts of the picture. Bring your scorecard to a first conversation with Russell, and we will tell you honestly whether we can help.